Tuesday, July 31, 2012

If he hollers, let him; it will be all that's left.


Considering the nature of Aristotelian narrative, it seems as though the denouement within Chester Himes’ novel, If He Hollers Let Him Go, or the falling action, is the series of events detailing Bob’s fall; he is victimized by Madge and the system. Thus, signifying the anagnorisis within the text, as the events that transpire between Bob and Mage within the closet, when Bob says, “look, baby, I don’t want you. I don’t want no part of you, that’s final.’ And I mean it” (Himes, 179). It is at this moment that Bob recognizes for himself this critical discovery of what he truly desires and rectifies the conflicting lust and repulsion he has for Madge. However, it is possible that along these lines, the anagnorisis actually occurs when he and Alice discuss their future. Bob considers marriage and children, a future despite his lack of faith in whites and America as a whole. It is this change in attitude, this calming/taming of the “beast,” which allows for the moment of catharsis. The reader’s heart strings are pulled once Bob is captured and forced to enlist to avoid persecution for the alleged rape. It isn’t that Bob sees sense; so much as he is no longer able to fight. His rage is knocked out of him, as when he falls during the scene with Madge. Society finally catches up to him and he is no longer able to fight. We feel for Bob because he was ready for a new start, a fresh start, despite all the victimization he has had to endure.  

Lust. Power. Life and Death


A topic that has monopolized my interest within Fanny Fern's novel is the character of Mrs. Hall, along with the relative ideas of power and dependency, which we have discussed in class.  Throughout the novel Mrs. Hall demonstrates how women of the day may have attained power within the 1850’s, solely by means of the men with whom they influence and navigate life. White women maneuvered within a sort of limbo of existence. They were the property of white men, but not quite the same as slaves in the fields (so long as they were submissive and delirious with denial). The power dynamics are most intriguing when considering that they may have influenced the general ideology of our “modernist” society. When first meeting Ruth, Mrs. Hall declares, “As to Ruth, I don’t know anything about her. Of course she is perfect in his eyes. I remember the time when he used to think me perfect” (10). It seems as though there is an oedipal, bestial sexual nature to their relationship. This leads me to wonder about the sexual implications of the past within the present day, and, whether they really have been significantly influenced by the past. We have all seen silly magazine articles and blurbs about what one’s favorite position “says” about the kind of person someone may be. What remnants of this past lay dormant as a sort of perverse subtext in heterosexual sexual intercourse? Do certain positions reflect general, primeval attitudes? If so, do particular positions originate from this time, or see a heyday in this time? And do others demonstrate the same attempt to attain power and/or dominance by way of the male gaze, or literal overpowering of a man’s most “male” parts through sexual conquest...definitely something to explore further within the text and others. 

Wednesday, July 4, 2012

Linda Grasso's "Anger in the House: Fanny Fern's Ruth Hall and The Redrawing of Emotional Boundaries in Mid-Nineteenth Century America": If You See Something, Say Something


Nadine Hamoui, a Muslim American speaker at a Densho event in 2003, used a public platform to discuss her experiences after the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks. She draws similarities between a personal incident (her family was detained by the government) with the experience of Japanese Americans after the attack on Pearl Harbor. Hamoui’s speech not only publicizes the injustice of her family’s detainment, but the reality of other Muslim Americans. Hamoui eventually says, “History doesn’t repeat itself, it’s people that repeat history.” Hamoui speech serves as an outline, illuminating how post 9/11, Muslim antagonism circumnavigates and perpetuates the hate and trauma of the terrorist attacks. And in the same air, Fanny Fern’s novel, Ruth Hall, sheds light on the plight of women in the 1850’s. Both mediums push back against tyranny, whether the setting be ones literal home, or ones homeland.

Linda Grasso’s article, “Anger in the House: Fanny Fern’s Ruth Hall and The Redrawing of Emotional Boundaries in Mid-Nineteenth Century America,” addresses the resulting controversy and the amorphous state of society, unhinging at the time Ruth Hall was published. While Grasso refrains from interjecting much of her own voice, her article does a good job of informing the reader on why the novel was such a catalyst for the public’s hyper-opinionated concern, by introducing the desperate premises of activists Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Caroline Dall. Most importantly, the article speaks on “abolitionist agitation” and how “woman’s rights activists were able to adapt and apply to their own purposes.” (Grasso, 254). ). For suffrage activist Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Ruth Hall provides a divine lesson on woman’s divinely inspired brain and muscle power (Grasso, 252). Women were finally, “vehemently rejecting a Jesus-like, feminine-styled doctrine of ‘Love your enemies’’ (Grasso, 255).The backlash resulting from the novel was only logical, for society feared the unknown horizon of change, as it was shifting away from a “harsh Calvinism” (Grasso, 258). 

However, Dall did not “regard woman’s public expression of anger as a socially acceptable political tool” for it was “inappropriate and crass” (Grasso, 257). In this way, Dall adhered to the norm of anger being a masculine attribute. And although, the autobiographical tale of Ruth Hall was seen as an angry prose-lashing by the public, Fern’s novel depicts a woman whom deals with her adverse circumstances of patriarchal injustice with grace and strength. And because it is a work of non-fiction it serves as a novel should in that it is a point for identification for Fern’s readership. The novel is authentic even more so by the utilization of the character of Halls’ mother-in-law. While Ruth is docile and abused by her family members, including her mother-in-law, Mis Hall is snarky and often combats in a passive-aggressive manner. This utilization of her character’s interaction with her husband only increases the novels revolutionary aesthetic; Mis Hall’s age give her actions more authenticity (Fern 66).